In a landmark paper titled “Migration,” finance luminaries Eugene Fama and Kenneth French uncover the dynamic mechanisms driving two of investing’s most studied phenomena: the small-cap and value premiums. Their findings challenge conventional wisdom and offer crucial insights for investors seeking to capture these return premiums.
The Surprising Source of Small-Cap Outperformance
The small-cap premium has long intrigued investors, but its true source may surprise many. Fama and French discover that the premium comes almost entirely from one source: small companies that graduate to large-cap status. Each year, roughly 8-12% of small stocks make this transition, generating significant returns in the process.
Conventional wisdom might suggest that big stocks becoming small would also significantly impact returns, but the research shows otherwise. While these negative migrations do generate substantial negative returns, they represent such a tiny fraction of large-cap portfolios that their impact on overall returns is minimal. This asymmetry helps explain the persistence of the small-cap premium over time.
The Triple Engine of Value Stock Returns
The value premium, it turns out, has three distinct drivers. First, value stocks that improve in quality and either migrate toward growth status or get acquired generate substantial positive returns. Second, growth stocks that deteriorate and shift toward value status create a drag on growth portfolio returns. Third, even value stocks that maintain their classification tend to outperform growth stocks that maintain theirs, though this effect is more modest.
Understanding Migration Patterns
The research reveals several persistent patterns in how stocks move between categories. Value stocks show a higher propensity to improve in classification than growth stocks do to maintain their status. Conversely, growth stocks are more likely to deteriorate in classification than value stocks. Among small caps, growth companies are more likely to achieve large-cap status than their value counterparts.
These patterns aren’t random – they reflect fundamental business dynamics. Value companies have more room for improvement and often benefit from restructuring or turnaround initiatives. Growth companies, facing intense competition and high expectations, frequently struggle to maintain their premium status.
Practical Applications
While written in 2007, Fama and French’s insights remain highly relevant today. In an era of rapid business transformation, understanding how and why stocks migrate between categories may be more important than ever for investors seeking to capture market premiums.
Understanding these migration patterns adds a crucial dynamic dimension to traditional value and small-cap investing approaches. Rather than viewing these effects as static phenomena, successful investors should consider the forces that drive stocks to transition between categories – for it is in these transitions that the greatest returns often lie.
Research Links
